Judging Jamie Lynn
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

Britney Spears' younger sister Jamie Lynn Spears announced that she’s pregnant. This is a girl who’s 16, rich and famous, and is now being held up as "responsible" for taking ownership and deciding to keep her baby.

Why isn’t anyone talking about why she’s pregnant in the first place? “It was a shock for both of us, so unexpected,” Jamie Lynn told Ok! magazine. “I was in complete and total shock and so was [my boyfriend].” She can’t possibly lack knowledge or access to birth control, so why was her pregnancy a shock? If you have sex without protection, you might get pregnant. NOT SHOCKING, right? Granted, she could have had a condom break or something, but that's why Plan B is available over-the-counter.

My beef isn’t with what she—or other girls in her position—decided to do with her pregnancy. But instead of using her situation (and spotlight) to mention the preventability of teen pregnancy, Jamie Lynn holds up abstinence as a reasonable solution for other girls. “I definitely don’t think it’s [premarital sex] something you should do; it’s better to wait,” she said. “But I can’t be judgmental because it’s a position I put myself in.” Jamie Lynn casts premarital sex as the problem when unprotected sex is clearly the issue at hand—thus passing up a perfect opportunity to slip the solution into the dialogue. 

A girl who’s a role model for millions of other young girls shouldn’t be heralded for failing to use contraception. Period.

And MSNBC definitely shouldn’t be running a poll on whether Jamie Lynn will be a better mother than Britney.


Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

  
Zoey 101 learns about the need for birth control
By Alyssa Dec 20th 2007 at 3:34 pm EST
If Jamie Lynn's pregnancy scares teenages who are sexually active into making sure they are using birth control if they are going to take on the responsibilities of having sex, then maybe something positive will have resulted from this situation.
Re: Zoey 101 learns about the need for birth control
By ashwini Dec 20th 2007 at 4:02 pm EST
I doubt that will happen--if young women and men don't have the correct information about how to use contraceptives in the first place, and they're certainly not getting the information from their schools, they're unlikely to start using contraceptives just because Jamie got pregnant. I agree with Annika--the issue here is a lack of information about safe and responsible sex.

I also am tickled to see that Britney and Jamie's mom's scheduled book--on "Christian parenting"--has been indefinitely postponed. Hmm, witholding information about contraception and safe sex--sounds pretty right-wing Christian to me. She should go ahead and write that book!
  
Keepping the baby
By Ekat Dec 20th 2007 at 4:30 pm EST
I think what Jamie has done is wrong. But, keeping the baby is right. Abortion is wrong. God talks about it in the Bible God's Holy Word. Even though she is just a teen and still has much more many years left, she's making the right choice. Not the choice about because it is wrong if you are 16, but kepping the baby will change her life the way that God wants it to.
  
Abstinence only education?
By Sonal Dec 20th 2007 at 4:53 pm EST
What a year it has been for the Spears family! What I simply cannot understand is why they would even leak this story to the press? With all the BAD press they've had this year, they should know better!

I totally agree with you Annika, she should use her celebrity (especially as a Nickolodean teen queen) to actually be the role model she claims she is.

The best part of this whole story is that the press is bringing up the parenting skills of her mom (who apparently was coming out with a book on parenting!) I think its time that we stop "abstinence only" education in our schools and start teaching SAFE sex, contraceptions, morning after pills... and Healthy relationships!
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress