Post from Ben Tuttle's Blog:
One Person Representing Race?
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

In attending the discussion about the Latino and African American Vote Panel yesterday there was a theme running through the speakers that caught my attention. There almost should have not been a panel on this issue at all. Let me explain what I mean.

The population of Latin Voters and African American voters has more to vote for than race, so why categorize them as such? They have such a wide economically and socially diverse population that they are not going to for vote as a group for the one candidate that appeals to them most. They just might have the issues to consider.

Panelist Dr. Eddie Glaude brings up the point that he has been asked more than once how the African American vote is going to go and he says “I don’t know. I can tell you how I’m going to vote. I don’t represent anyone else.”

Another panel guest Gebe Martinez made the point that the younger generation favors a new hope message, whereas the older generations of Latino voters like what they have seen in the White House before. The only problem is that this is appealing to races across the board. Gebe brings up is that the general population believes that every Latino’s top concern is immigration. It turns out that education is number one.

In a campaign that is not focused on race or gender, why are we still categorizing race? There are so many factors that go into a race as largely publicized as this one that we should not tailor any categorization as broad as race. How is the Latino and African American vote this year going to go? They cast more than one vote.


Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

  
But the Media likes the race designator!
By Sara Feb 27th 2008 at 12:13 pm EST
But of course this campaign is focused on race and gender...it makes the work easier for the media. I mean, it might not be best for the people, or issue voters, or anyone else, but how else could they continue 24 hr news coverage in such a long election cycle? I'm as sick of the "how will African American women voters decide how to vote" as much as anyone...but you also run out of news after a while, and this seems to sustain the frenzied coverage for as long as possible.

On a side note, I wished the panel had focused more on what issues are important to communities as opposed to why the race breakdown doesn't work. I mean, I think its an important point, but it wasn't until the question and answer that the issue of education within the Latin@ community came up, and no mention was made of higher incarceration rates among youth of color and impacts on voting....but a panel can't ever be perfect.
  
Sub-categorization apparently helps the media
By Preston Mitchum Feb 27th 2008 at 5:37 pm EST
I agree with you and Sara. However, simply because the media has nothing better to discuss does not make it right that they decide to discuss this. Why the Black vote? The White vote? The woman vote? The man vote? Can I just have a vote. I can see why these matter to people who love statistics, but I do not understand why this is important to voters who are truly interested in poltics. And this is coming from someone who focuses on identity poitics.

You would be amazed how many times I have been asked how Blacks feel about certain issues, as if I can speak for the whole race. It's absurd. I do understand why it is done for the most part, but as said earlier, it does not make it better.
  
Identity Politics No More?
By Tyler Cruse Feb 28th 2008 at 1:18 am EST
Boy, you people are starting to venture off the plantation here. Don't you realize that Democrat/Progressive power is absolutely dependent on identity politics and having various groups vote as a monolithic block, instantly demonizing and marginalizing anyone who dares vary from the group (Justice Thomas, Thomas Sowell, et al)?
Re: Identity Politics No More?
By Nazik Feb 28th 2008 at 4:55 pm EST
wow, racist much?
Re: Identity Politics No More?
By Tyler Cruse Feb 28th 2008 at 6:17 pm EST
I agree. Let's start doing what we can to rid the progressive movement of this unconscious racism that is almost never discussed.
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress