Post from Reading List:
The Wal-Mart Enigma
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

Just as I finished reading the good news that Wal-Mart has joined a pro-universal health care coalition including the SEIU, AT&T, Intel, and my employer, the Center for American Progress, I clicked to another screen and learned that an immense class-action lawsuit alleging widespread sex discrmination at Wal-Mart stores moved forward yesterday. Over 2 million female Wal-Mart workers are elligible to join the suit, making it the largest sex discrimination suit ever filed in the United States. The lead plaintiff, 56-year old Betty Dukes, claims pay and promotion discrimination. It took Dukes three years to advance from cashier to customer service representative, even though men hired after her were promoted in as little as 90 days. Two-thirds of Wal-Mart workers are women, but only one-third of managers.

All of which begs the question: How should progressives engage with a corporation with so many widely-publicized labor abuses (including locking workers inside stores and denying them overtime), an arguably disasterous footprint on the American urban and suburban landscape, and yet a realistic, even pathbreaking, attitude about the health care crisis? When I interviewed SEIU president Andy Stern in November, he said, "We applaud good behavior and we hold people accountable for bad behavior."

It seems like public relations fiascos are just about the only criticisms Wal-Mart responds to. It's good news that they've joined the SEIU and CAP to make progress on health care, but it can't cover up Wal-Mart's despicable record on labor. I hope that as Wal-Mart works in the new coalition, they find themselves embarassed enough by their labor abuses to make some serious changes. Because how can you support a worker's right to health insurance but deny them time off to visit the doctor? How can you want to insure a single mother's child, but "mommy track" that worker, cheating her out of raises and promotions? We should expect better from the nation's largest employer.


Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

  
yea
By TFI Feb 7th 2007 at 12:54 pm EST
Yea I agree. And I have some doubts about whether or not Stern's strategy is working, or even has the potential to work. He has sort of moved away from conflict to cooperation. That's ok, but unions need SOME way to get corporations to do the right thing.
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress