Post from Marc Loi's Blog:
The role of male students in feminism/women's studies.
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.
What exactly is the role of male students when it comes to feminism - especially on campus?

Truth be told - I do feel as though I am intruding and taking over what rightfully belongs to women - feminism and the fight for equal rights.

As somewhat of a campus political activist, I am the one telling every one else what problems are facing women.

As a double major, one of which is women's studies, I feel as though I am intruding even further - in a classroom setting in which women are supposed to explore and discuss their ideas and ideals, I am the one person in there who really has no place in there …

So now comes the question …what is the role of male students in feminism and women's studies classes?

Trust me - the majority of the males who are dedicated to feminism and learning more about the plight of women are genuine (or though there are a few who are in the program for a piece of ass - which they find out quick that it doesn't work that way), and we truly want to help out, but we also don't want to feel like assholes in dominating everything.

We're already privileged as is.

So, again, what are the role of male politicians, student political activists and students in feminism?

Reader Comments
  
Question:
By Superduperficial Jun 14th 2006 at 3:14 pm EDT
Truth be told - I do feel as though I am intruding and taking over what rightfully belongs to women - feminism and the fight for equal rights.



Uh, no, it doesn't "belong" to anyone. Good public policy belongs to everyone, because it benefits all of society.

That's like saying "labor policy belongs to the unions".


As somewhat of a campus political activist, I am the one telling every one else what problems are facing women.



Feminism isn't just about "the problems facing women" - it's about how we should go about constructing an equal and fair society.


in a classroom setting in which women are supposed to explore and discuss their ideas and ideals, I am the one person in there who really has no place in there …



If that really all a women's studies class is for? What a waste. You'd think there'd be some academic rigor involved if credit's going to be awarded.

Oh, and talk about reinforcing the illiberal, unprogressive idea that "to be myself i need to be around people who are just like me".


but we also don't want to feel like assholes in dominating everything.

We're already privileged as is.



The fact that you're approaching this issue with a boatload of whiny guilt just demonstrates how unprivileged men truly are.

The whole idea of "male privilege" is true elsewhere in the world, but largely a myth in America when you actually look at the numbers and the social customs involved.


So, again, what are the role of male politicians, student political activists and students in feminism?



Articulating one's own vision of a fair and equal society and fighting for it.
Re: Question:
By RevolutionAM Jun 14th 2006 at 5:25 pm EDT
Oh, and talk about reinforcing the illiberal, unprogressive idea that "to be myself i need to be around people who are just like me".


If the issue revolves around coercive social arrangements, it DOES make sense to discuss and analyze it in a different social setting devoid of the coercion.


The whole idea of "male privilege" is true elsewhere in the world, but largely a myth in America when you actually look at the numbers and the social customs involved.


Numbers, like rape statistics and pay differentials, and social customs, like spousal abuse, hiring discrimination based on pregnancy (and even pregnancy likelihood!), and the tendency for men to ignore women when speaking or asking questions. I'm sure Marc, since he's taking these classes, can think of many more.
  
A good question
By RevolutionAM Jun 14th 2006 at 5:17 pm EDT
We have to be allies. You're already doing more than most guys in college do; a useful role of a male student in a feminism/women's studies class is to help the class explore male culture from a first-hand perspective. You'll be able to provide insight when talking about, in broad brushstrokes, how a guy's mind works; you can also offer a peek into the social world between guys that most women never get a chance to experience.

You also serve as an example to some of the more closed-minded students that not all men are evil misogynistic assholes.

Just make sure you don't dominate conversation in class; as a feminist activist you need to make sure women are getting equal speaking time (and equal consideration!) in organizational settings. Though perhaps the most productive thing you can do is be a feminist around your guy friends. Get them to stop using "like a girl" or "fag" as generic insults, at least when they're around you. Get some of your declared non-feminist guy friends to go to feminist events, etc.
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress