Post from Todd Hill's Blog:
Lack of Recruitment Goals Might Lead to Draft
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.
As expected the Army has missed its recruitment goal by 25% for May. This after revising their monthly goal numbers lower, as not to appear worse then the 1/4th these revised expectations reflect. The National Guard and Reserve have had similar problems filling coffers with fresh bodies to fight a war still lacking an overall mission and strategy. The marines are so desperate at this point they are resorting to kidnapping, lying, and aggressive intimidation tactics to secure fresh bodies. Does anyone else feel a draft?

You better, and it is a breeze that is swirling under the radar that parents and students should be feeling like a tingle on your skin. As the neocons continue and rattle sabers with Iran, threaten North Korea, watch China build it’s empire, and inflame terrorism as a result of the Iraqi invasion; America’s all volunteer army remains in dire condition. According to Retired Army Colonel Jack Jacobs, the military ranks are now resorting to retaining high school dropouts, drug addicts, pedophiles, and the otherwise banished from society groups, as defenders of freedom. Troop deployments have forced soldiers into a third tour of duty and continue and pressure military families at home to survive on limited economic resources. Republican Governor Rick Perry of Texas told gay and lesbian veterans that if they don’t like anti-marriage laws in Texas then they can leave the state last Sunday as he was pandering to the religious right. The Pentagon discharged a wounded gay sergeant after requesting to return to duty as an “out” soldier. Our priorities are misguided at best, completely lost at worst. Either way, if the majority party does not shift back into reality as soon as possible, a draft will be the only method capable of retaining this neoconservative democracy installation project in the Middle East. That means, as happened during Vietnam, middle to poor class students will be supplementing another political war.

William Thrower Sr., a retired sergeant major living in Arlington, Texas, served over 30 years actively in the United States Army. Mr. Thrower, a young African American from Georgia in 1963, voluntarily signed up and served two tours in Vietnam. When asked his opinion on the draft it was his firm belief that it is not likely at this time; however, he does believe it would be a good thing for young Americans to experience. When he retired in 1991, the sergeant major learned shoe repairing and opened his own business as a result. The Army taught him skills he would have otherwise not received: discipline he sorely lacked, the strong character he wanted, and the responsibility he needed to be a productive member in society. The walls in his store are covered with memories of his 30+ years of service. Most striking to me was the poster of a weeping man leaning on the Vietnam War memorial. His shadow reflected soldiers in Vietnam era uniforms reaching out to touch the emotional veteran. That picture helped me to reflect on the many youth who were drafted during Vietnam, many our ages and much younger. I began to think of the feelings they had in the pits of their stomachs as they continued to witness Vietnam slowly slip into a desperate mission to save face. Like the students of the past, it is my belief that my generation is not prepared for a military draft. Nor are they paying as much attention as they should to the current foreign policy quagmire that continues to slip into a desperate mission to save face. Our generation is about to inherit the biggest foreign policy endeavor of the 21st century and many of us are still oblivious to the world outside of their own. Ladies and gentlemen, do you feel that draft?

Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

  
Yes, Todd, I do- but it doesn't have to be this way
By jg Jun 10th 2005 at 9:15 am EDT
The more I think about it, I feel like it's somewhat inevitable. Given how badly the Bush administration has bungled military preparation for Iraq (not to mention our continued problems with Afghanistan . . . not that anyone seems to remember we're still engaged there), it seems increasingly clear that if it wants to attain its grandiose foreign policy goals, it will have to increase troop numbers. And given how badly they tend to bungle these things, I highly doubt people are going to be signing up enthusiastically to go to Fallujah.

There's one other important element here: the income demographic of today's military. Currently, we seem to have what is a perniciously unofficial draft- a poverty draft, whereby poor, largely minority youths who can't afford to go to college see the military as their only viable career path. They end up fighting a war that benefits corporate fatcats. How fair is that? You might make a progressive case for a draft based on notions of burden sharing and collective class responsibility- I'm not saying I believe that argument, but I'm just putting it out there.

Now, having written all of this, I want to make clear that a policy change on military recruitment could allow us to avert a draft. The Bush administration and Congress must immediately work to implement the recommendations made by CAP's Progressive Priorities Project in a report they published earlier this year. You can read that report: http://www.americanprogress.org/site/pp.asp?c=biJR J8OVF&b=269841. I'm just thinking out loud here, but given how students mobilized around the filibuster, I wonder if we might do something similar to pressure Congress to adopt the recommendations made in this report. If there was ever a public policy debate young people had a stake in, it's this one. Kudos to Todd for bringing this up.
Siddique, When you're right, you're right!
By DanDean Jun 10th 2005 at 9:32 pm EDT
I believe that you wrapped that up in a well
thought out and succinct manner!
Right On!
By ToddHill Jun 12th 2005 at 5:55 pm EDT
I went on vacation for a few days but wanted to drop that blog before I left to see what attention it got. Damn good analysis, Asheesh. The Campus Progress analysis is point for point what our Foreign Policy approach should be for the remainder of the 21st century.

I too agree about the state of the draft. It is inevitable at this point, no turning back now. But agree we must begin pressuring Congress to act on these recommendations PRIOR to a draft taking place.

At this point, such a foreign policy endorsement would at least give current military personnel a strategy. They don't have it now and it hasn't been updated since 2002, as noted effectively by Asheesh. When the draft begins, at the least a new mission will have been formed, complete with startgegy and goals to effectively carry it out.

But, unfortunately, we have seen NO reason to believe that the Bush administration is prepared to remove its veil of arrogance and wake up to reality. That should really send a shiver down your spine.

Great post!

Todd
  
Recruiting on College Campuses
By gqmartinez Jun 10th 2005 at 2:31 pm EDT
One thing I find odd is that many progressives
champion the idea of banning military
recruiters
on college campuses (specifically Law Schools)
because of the "don't ask, don't tell" policy.
I
think the anti-gay bias of the military leaders
is
both wrong and bad policy, but doesn't this also
seem to further propogate the recruitment of
non-college people, i.e., the "poverty draft"?

  
History Repeating Itself
By DanDean Jun 10th 2005 at 9:24 pm EDT
How many wars with little or no purpose will we
elect to participate in? When will the campuses
wake up? Not since WWII has there been a war with
a real purpose. Being in Iraq has nothing to do
with protecting "freedom". Neither did Viet Nam
for that matter. All in retrospect, but watch
McNamara's "The Fog of War".
  
It Is Getting Drafty...
By Bluejacket Jun 14th 2005 at 4:54 pm EDT
It is going to happen, but I doubt it will be
something anyone sees coming. It will be dressed
up as something else, so the Chicken Hawks can say
"See, no draft..."

Really good article. As recruitment falls, the
military is going to have do to something to keep
up it's troop numbers. They have already gone
after veterans, and stretched out the Reservists
as far as possible. And, I am wondering how many
people are signing back up after spending years in
Iraq with months off in between.

As far as a "poverty draft" goes, watch Gangs Of
New York (or better yet, read the book) or look at
Vietnam. People like Cheney and Bush were able to
weasel their way out through high contacts or
sudden impending fatherhood. In the Civil War,
people were able to buy their way out for $300,
but Irish immigrants did not have that sort of
money. The Draft Riots went on for days, and Union
soliders, straight from Gettysburg, had to be
called in to quell the riots. I am sure people
with wealth would find some way to keep their
children out of this war.
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress