Post from Ashwini's Blog:
Happy 60th Independence Day to India!
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

60 years ago, on August 15th, 1947, India declared independence from Great Britain.  We've come a long way, and there are marvelous things and horrible things that have happened in our post-indpendence years.  Check out the Hindustan Times feature on "India at 60" for more.

I believe that in the history of the world, there has not been a more genuinely democratic struggle for freedom than ours. I read Carlyle’s French Resolution while I was in prison, and Pandit Jawaharlal has told me something about the Russian revolution. But it is my conviction that inasmuch as these struggles were fought with the weapon of violence they failed to realize the democratic ideal. In the democracy which I have envisaged, a democracy established by non-violence, there will be equal freedom for all. Everybody will be his own master. It is to join a struggle for such democracy that I invite you today. Once you realize this you will forget the differences between the Hindus and Muslims, and think of yourselves as Indians only, engaged in the common struggle for independence.

-Mohandas Karamchand (Mahatma) Gandhi


Reader Comments
  
Fuck Gandhi.
By Superduperficial Aug 16th 2007 at 2:56 am EDT
His "nonviolence in all circumstances" bullshit was and is morally evil, as when he condemned the Jews of the Warsaw ghetto uprising for fighting back against the Nazis.

He did a lot of good, sure, but a lot of it was done for the wrong reasons, and he did enough harm to the world that his overall moral legacy is a checkerboard at best.

Like the significantly more reprehensible Mother Theresa, however, he's got a damn good posthumous PR team. The name "Gandhi" will continue to serve as a facile stand-in for "Whatever we currently happen to believe in" for many years hence.
Re: Fuck Gandhi.
By ashwini Aug 16th 2007 at 10:56 am EDT
Yes there are many things that are extremely problematic, if not completely reprehensible, about Gandhi. I personally believe that self-sacrifice and leading a life of voluntary suffering is complete bullshit. But to say that he acted for "the wrong reasons" or to say that he did more harm to the world than good I think is ridiculous. He helped to free hundreds of millions of people from an oppressive imperial power that had no regard for the lives or well-being of their "subjects." And many of his theories of non-violence are extremely relevant and have been important to some of our greatest leaders for justice, such as MLK and Nelson Mandela.
Re: Fuck Gandhi.
By Ravi Aug 29th 2007 at 2:36 am EDT
I could list a thousand things that support the belief that Gandhi was evil. If you had ever familiarized yourself with Gandhi's own writings while in South Africa, it would be painfully obvious that he was extremely racist and believed Black Africans to be inferior in every way. He truly despised Black people--if you want to disprove that point, I challenge you to find a single photograph of Gandhi with any Black person. Considering that he lived in a majority Black country for over 20 years, you'd think that would be a simple task.

If you think that Gandhi helped to free anyone at all, you are extremely naive and ignorant of Indian history. Gandhi did nothing to hasten Indian independence whatsoever, and according to V.S. Naipal, was so erratic and counterproductive to the independence movement, that he probably delayed Indian independence by about 20 years.

Gandhi forced little girls to get buck naked and sleep in his bed while he was buck naked. That is what I call a sexual predator.

Gandhi never bothered to consult his wife before unilaterally deciding that they had had sex for the last time.

Gandhi killed his wife by forbidding her to be injected with penicillin when she was sick. And he had the audacity to write her a letter telling her that she ought to be happy about dying.

Gandhi disowned his son for wanting an education that consisted of anything other than sitting and listening to Gandhi's musings on the nature of God and existence, and wanting to get married. He never spoke to him again and forbade his family from ever corresponding with him again.

Gandhi said that the Jews of Europe should have thrown themselves off the cliffs into the sea, that they should have offered their throats up to the butchers' knives. He urged Churchill to surrender to Hitler.


Etc. etc. etc. I could go on all night, but I won't. Educate yourself about the real Gandhi, not the myth of Gandhi and you might feel foolish that you had been deceived for so long by the Indian establishment. Gandhi was pure evil. He makes me nauseous.
Re: Fuck Gandhi.
By Ravi Aug 29th 2007 at 2:44 am EDT
MLK and the other leaders of the SCLC would NEVER have gone to India to learn Gandhian philosophy and tactics if they hadn't been tricked into believing that he believed in equality of all races. He actually fought to have Indians in South Africa be treated better than the Black people who were at the bottom of South African society, quite rightly in his opinion. He never renounced the writings that he wrote in his newspaper, "Indian Opinion" in Durban which were unquestionably extremely racist. The Cult of Gandhi pulled a snow job on MLK and his colleagues. Too bad they didn't read Gandhi's own writings on racial separatism and Black inferiority.
  
gandhi accidental hero
By japs Dec 24th 2007 at 3:20 pm EST
Gandhi is an accidental hero.gandhi was never in favour of independent india.He demanded a system within british rule that allow indian to govern themself. He was in favour of what we may call half independence.With rise of extremist wing in india which demanded purna swaraj(FULL INDEPENDENCE) he found his popularity dipping so he raised demand purna swaraj.also British do not left india because of him but because after world war 2 they were not in position to govern such a vast country.
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress