Afghan Rape Victim in Jail
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

An AP story reported today that a woman in Afghanistan who was raped and abused was arrested and given a four year sentence for adultery and escaping her house.  The young woman said she was kidnapped by a neighbor and delivered to an Afghan man along with her 3-year old son.  The man raped her for three months.  Afraid of losing her son, she attempted to run away.  When she was found and brought home, the man beat her and her son.  She reported it to the authorities, they came and arrested him (who is serving 20 years for the murder of the 3-year old boy he beat) and her.  Given the four year sentence on December 5 and now in jail, she asks "Why am I here?"  The chief prosecutor on the case, Abdul Qayum, said “She committed adultery.  It was rape, but the woman is also guilty.” 

After suggesting that she got a light sentence, Qayum said, "This is Afghanistan, not America.”  While his comment suggests the difficulty of applying human rights standards, especially women’s rights, cross-culturally, this is a huge setback to the past improvements for Afghan women.  Although the Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission documented an increase in the number of women complaining of violence, this case threatens that improvement and could set a precedent for women to keep quiet despite horrific conditions and abuse. 


Reader Comments
  
This also exemplifies...
By Superduperficial May 1st 2008 at 4:40 am EDT
...why as progressives, we shouldn't blindly accept the precepts of other cultures as automatically valid -- in much the same way that we shouldn't hesitate to challenge the norms of our own culture when we find them wanting.
  
What a horrific life...
By MadChatter May 9th 2008 at 2:08 pm EDT
however, it is not America, so please stop comparing it to us. These people live in a tribal society which is completely unlike our own. Although I don't and can't agree with their laws, one cannot help another person who won't help themselves. Something like this can only be discontinued if the society as a whole decides they won't live this way anymore. Outsiders can only help when/if that happens. When that happens, please let me know.
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress