MTV evokes the Holocaust, and I'm confused.
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

Via Huffington Post. 

 I can't decide what is most upsetting/confounding about this situation. 

The idea that MTV is using the Holocaust to startle teens? Or that the message of these ads is unclear?

The HuffPo writer ponders the complexity of media influence, corporations, and government regulation, but I would like to get more to the point of this particular reference. Ads are here and here

Why is MTV trying to scare teenagers? Maybe I missed something, but I was under the impression that we're in the middle of a very exciting presidential election with a race between very distinguished and talented candidates on both sides. In what way does that signal impending systematic imprisonment and murder for "people like us"?

 



It doesn't! As the Huffington Post points out, a more contemporary example would have better served a message of action and resistance. If they're set on bringing genocide in to this, maybe they could compare real examples of genocides and ethnic cleansing going on now. Because it does happen, is happening, and is important to think about and act on. But these ads do not accomplish that. This is simply a replication of empty scare tactics with no real message or call to action.

I understand that people are generally unhappy with the current administration and that its fun to be dramatic about how bad things are or could be in America, but this is just excessive and offending.  


Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

  
wha??
By kickingtelevision Apr 7th 2008 at 2:07 pm EDT
mtv- somehow you have managed to belittle genocide- i didn't even know this was possible.
  
no way.
By Tanya Paperny Apr 7th 2008 at 6:15 pm EDT
I hadn't seen this before, so thanks for the link. Typical of MTV to push out these blanket and vague statements (do something, get involved, think, vote), and try to push the envelope, but fail miserably.

All bad.
  
comment
By Kayla Apr 8th 2008 at 10:57 am EDT
I wish I could tell what makes these commercials relevant; I think that's the most frustrating thing about them.
Think about what
By Erika A Apr 11th 2008 at 1:39 pm EDT
I agree. It's definitely a shocking ad and I guess the main point is if we do not think, things can get massively out of control, but like Kayla, I wish they linked it to something specific and current. Why are they playing this commercial now? What exactly are we suppose to be thinking about and why are we drawing in this particular piece of history to remind us about it?
  
The Real MTV Holocaust video on think.mtv.com
By daniel2 May 4th 2008 at 4:26 pm EDT
Hello all

If you want to watch the original two videos that are posted on the MTV website think.mtv.com, so you can see the context, and the resources they suggest young people use to understand the Holocaust, and preventing another such terrible tragedy, please check out these two links:
Subway: Link and
Family Room: Link
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress