Post from Kay Steiger's Blog:
The Dying J-School
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

One of Chronicle's blogs today discusses how journalism schools are slow to adapt to the changing nature of media. At a conference of J-School educators this weekend, "citizen journalism has moved from heresy — a topic to be considered, if at all, only in side conferences and hallways — to something that, while still not widely accepted, is at least of interest."

As a J-School graduate myself, I felt like I started a bit behind the starting gate. It took me a while to acclimate to blogs because in J-School I was taught that they aren't real journalism and we should reject them. This is mainly because journalism classes are taught by more or less retired journalists. The really cutting-edge journalists all have, well, jobs in journalism. Now that blogs have been (rather slowly) adapted to MSM. (Rick Hertzberg is even blogging now, albeit rather badly).

What I was most disappointed about in my J-School education was the way all of my classes basically ignored the fact that the Internet existed. They told us it was better to pick up the phone (it is, although the Internet is a great way to do a lot of background research for a story), go to the library (for what?), and never ever believe anything printed by a blog (!). I didn't learn HTML except by my own initiative. I never learned to write a blog post until I got a job at a magazine.

This makes me wary of the future of journalism, since we seem to have two streams of people entering the field: a group trained in ethics and reporting who think the future is in newspapers (it's not), and a group of people with no ethics or reporting training whatsoever who understand how to write blogs and get them read.


Reader Comments
  
maybe
By Barack Obama Aug 13th 2007 at 12:59 pm EDT
we should just pay more attention to people with Ph.Ds.
Re: maybe
By Superduperficial Aug 13th 2007 at 9:44 pm EDT
So, would you like to be the first one to delve into the pronouncements of Dr. Ralph Reed?
Re: maybe
By Barack Obama Aug 14th 2007 at 2:11 pm EDT
Clearly, I meant: people with Ph.Ds from renowned institutions. After all, these are largely the folks who set public policy. Look at where the people who have sat on the council of economic advisors got their doctorates.
  
Good Point
By Michael Corcoran Aug 13th 2007 at 6:39 pm EDT
My j-school (Emerson) was pretty good about teaching us how to make a web site, use flash, etc .... and I am thankful for that.

However, many of the old-school print teachers had the same reactionary dismissiveness towards web stories and blogs. The irony of course, is that web skills are coveted so much by employers.

I never understood why instead of telling students to avoid trusting blogs or wiki-type sites right away. WHy not instruct them to scrutinize them diligently, as any journalist should do to any source, regardless of where it was printed (including in reputable print sources)?
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress