Post from Thomas Coen's Blog:
Backdoor Nativism
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

The economic barriers of immigrating to the U.S. and becoming a citizen just got a whole lot higher.

New fees went into effect yesterday to help the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) pay for its operations.   The cost for registering for permanent residence or adjusting one's status skyrocketed more than 186% to $930, more than the per capita GDP of 22 countries.  Applying for naturalization rose more than 80% to $595 and the petition fee for a foreign relative exploded almost 87% to $355.



A 1988 law passed by Congress mandated that the USCIS pay for its services solely with the fees it collects from applicants.  The backlog of applicants has left immigration officials with little choice but to raise the fees, yet those fees are now beyond exorbitant for people with little money to squander on American bureaucracy.  As a New York Times editorial puts it, "With one hand, Lady Liberty lifts her lamp beside the golden door. With the other, she roots around in an immigrant's wallet, plucking out bills."  Jeanne Butterfield, executive director of the American Immigration Lawyers Association, aptly remarks, "'I don't think the cost of overhauling the bureaucracy should be on the backs of prospective immigrants.''

This new "tax" on those trying to achieve the "American Dream," trying to build a better life for their family and children, is a regressive tax bordering on nativism.  It is throwing up obstacles to one of the most economically vulnerable groups, trying to ensure that they don't succeed.  It is another example of the U.S. government taking advantage of a marginalized group with little voice and power.

Reader Comments
  
I couldn't afford it either
By Cara Boekeloo Jul 31st 2007 at 11:48 am EDT
Excellent post. In the words of a column mate, I couldn't afford to become a citizen at those rates.
  
Perhaps this is a good thing?
By Superduperficial Jul 31st 2007 at 8:29 pm EDT
The nice part about pricing is that it helps sort out people's preferences.

Given how much American citizenship is *worth*, I'm surprised we don't charge more.

Also, we currently have a relative glut of unskilled labor, especially if we legalize the current illegal immigrants through some form of amnesty program.

What we want to be attracting is more *skilled* labor - I'd start by absolutely removing any cap on H1B visas.

To the extent that higher fees are biased in favor of attracting the immigrants we benefit more from, it makes sense.
Re: Perhaps this is a good thing?
By Thomas Coen Aug 3rd 2007 at 3:51 pm EDT
Superduperficial's free-market justification for exorbitant immigration fees is completely off the mark. He turns immigration politics into a cold, callous supply and demand game forgetting that there are real people involved who come from different circumstances and backgrounds. An immigrant from Spain has an entirely different economic situation on average than an immigrant from the Botswana because of how currencies are valued and their respective per capita GDP's. We should have an immigration policy that is fair for all citizens of the world, not just those from rich Western countries, and fair to all people, not just those who grew up in a privileged household. America flourishes because of its diversity and immigration fees should not be used as a way bar certain groups from coming to this country.
Re: Perhaps this is a good thing?
By arlynbabes Apr 25th 2008 at 2:29 pm EDT
Now I realize that is not easy to have a US citizenship. You need to file a documents and also pay an amount that is so high for me. It's so costly to be have that citizenship.

New York-based immigration attorneys announce the launch of a U.S. immigration law resource
website; assists aliens in becoming green card holders and U.S. citizens and fights deportation.

New York-based Immigration Lawyers Law Offices of
Marina Shepelsky, P.C. (www.eusvisa.com) is pleased to announce the launch of its U.S. Immigration
Law resource website Link. This revolutionary website will offer U.S. Immigration Law
articles, useful attorney advice, forms for various immigration needs, “How To” advisories, the latest
news by U.S.C.I.S. and comments by immigration lawyers, case studies, testimonials, practical advice,
user-friendly site navigation and much much more.
The main focus of Link is to provide users with educational information about the U.S.
immigration system and help aliens accomplish their dream of becoming U.S. residents.
Law Offices of Marina Shepelsky, P.C. offers services for immigrants across the United States' legal
matters such as immigration court representation, asylum, deportation defense, green card petitions
through family members, adjustment of status, abused spouse petitions, family and employment-based
immigration, fiancee K-1 visas, spousal K-3 visas, H-1B visas, extraordinary ability visas, and motions
and appeals to the Board of Immigration Appeals.
Law Offices of Marina Shepelsky, P.C. are experts in working with USCIS centers, Immigration Courts,
and U.S. Consulates worldwide.
At Law Offices of Marina Shepelsky, P.C., all cases are handled by knowledgeable experienced
immigration attorneys dedicated to the exclusive practice of immigration law. Each client is treated with
careful individualized attention and respect.
Link attorneys believe that immigration clients deserve professional, respectful treatment
and apply their up-to-date experience and knowledge of the myraid of immigration laws and related
caselaw to each case.
No case is too small for Law Offices of Marina Shepelsky, P.C. and each case deserves attention and
careful consideration. Link attorneys and staff take the time to develop a strategy for success in
every case and explain this strategy in detail to the clients, so the firm and the client work as a team.
Link attorneys create a step-by-step plan for each case and make sure each client
understands both the “big picture” and the minute details.
Law Offices of Marina Shepelsky, P.C. is a multi-lingual firm. For the clients' convenience, Law Offices
of Marina Shepelsky, P.C. and Link attorneys and staff speak Russian, Ukrainian, Polish,
Moldavian, and Romanian languages.

Law Offices of Marina Shepelsky, P.C. and Link proudly serve immigration clients in all
states across the U.S. and abroad.
Link welcomes calls and emails from all over the world and serves immigration law needs
for clients of every background. Link
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress