Rocks in our Heads
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.
Following up on Geoff Aung's piece, my favorite political records are not witty allegories or cryptic paintings. They’re unsubtle and uncool, and heart-on-sleeve or totally angry about something that actually happened (mostly). Read my list of ten or so and then post some of your picks.

“Bonzo Goes To Bitburg,” Ramones (1985). Liberal rage, Jewish rage, New York rage, punk rage, whatever, Joey is totally pissed off about Reagan’s 1985 visit to a cemetery where Nazi SS storm troopers are buried. In fact, he’s pissed about the whole Reagan presidency. Harmonies and glockenspiel on top of loud punk guitars and Joey’s venomous vocals equal an exhilarating three minute thrill ride. Your brain will hang upside down.

“The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll”(1964) and “George Jackson” (1971), Bob Dylan. A couple of real people get killed, race is involved, and Bob’s on the scene. “Hattie Carroll” is a tearjerker – Bob even tells you precisely when to cry – about a Maryland society brat who, in 1963, slams his cane down on a hotel kitchen worker. Ms. Carroll had 10 children. She deserves dignity; her family deserves justice; they get neither. Meanwhile, in 1960, George Jackson, age 19, is locked up for robbing a gas station of $71. He never gets out. In 1971, he and two other inmates at Soledad Prison in California are accused of murdering a guard. Before Jackson can stand trial, guards kill him. According to Bob, “They were scared of his love.” He adds, “Sometimes I think this whole world is one big prison yard. Some of us are prisoners. The rest of us are guards.” Not sure what all that means – sounds kind of dopey – but the performance is piercing. You want the acoustic one (45 vinyl, Dutch 2003 CD, or bootleg), not the “big band version.”

“When Will We B Paid,” Prince (2004). Not the syth-laden b-side, but the straightforward acoustic guitar version from last year’s tour. Remember the “Slave” notation painted on his face during his dust-up with Warner Records? In 2004, grinning, he asked for more, singing the Staple Singers song in front of mixed houses: When will we be paid for the work we’ve done?

“Piss Factory,” Patti Smith (1974). Really bad working conditions and bad-attituded coworkers and she’s got to get out of there and get on the train to New York.

“God Save the Queen,” Sex Pistols (1976). The beginning of the end for the rotting Windsor house and a classic expression of hopeless youthfulness. Cynical, packaged anger, but biting, bilious, and brilliant anyway. And where d’ya think we got the idea for our Campus Progress ad?

“Tramp the Dirt Down,” Elvis Costello (1989). Regarding the class-warfare-waging PM Margaret Thatcher, Elvis is direct: He looks forward to her death.

“Give Ireland Back to the Irish,” Paul McCartney, and “Luck of the Irish,” John Lennon (both 1972). After dueling in an earlier pair of songs about who sucked worse, John and Paul each release post-Bloody Sunday songs (Paul first), about how their native country was screwing their ancestral one. Paul’s song is pretty pedestrian and – surprise! – sappy, but he gets an A for earnestness. John’s has a beautiful melody with some real vinegar in the singing, especially in various demos that float around, although Yoko’s chirping in the middle is … annoying.

“Washington Bullets,” The Clash (1981). Not a tirade against Wes Unseld and Elvin Hayes, but a patient but firm, tropically-infused recounting of various acts of U.S., um, interference in Latin American. Concludes by praising the Carter Administration for staying out of Nicaragua, and then slamming Russian, Chinese, and British imperialism.

“Don’t Be A Drop-Out,” James Brown (1966). Pretty detailed story about some guy who didn’t finish school. James suggests you listen to that loserish guidance counselor: “Well, kids, stay in school; Don’t be no drag; Let the fool advise you; And stay out of that bag.” After all, “Without an education, you might as well be dead.”

Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

  
No real list, but
By August J. Pollak Mar 4th 2005 at 9:47 am EST
I don't really have a top ten list of
politically-motivating songs or anything like
that, but I certainly have a few favorites.

Despite the fact that it'll get me accused of
being an American-hating commie for the second
time this morning, I think the best "message rock"
actually came from a Canadian group called Moxy
Fruvous. They wrote "The Gulf War Song" during
Desert Storm and it's still great to listen to,
and relevant, today. Unfortunately, so is their
song "The Greatest Man in America," which is a
sarcastic salute to Rush Limbaugh.

Randy Newman has a couple of great ones, too.
Though I know none of you college students steal
music... yup... I should point out that getting
Newman's greatest hits CD is worth it for the
liner notes alone, including where he explains the
message of "Sail Away" and the fact that it's
actually based on a real American pro-slavery
jingle from the 18th century.

David already covered the usual Dylan and Ramones
necessity, but I think it goes without saying we
have to add U2 in there.

I have a special admiration with Dylan's "The
Legend of Hurricane Carter" but for personal
reasons as well as the message of the song. I'm
actually from Teaneck, New Jersey, which is about
ten miles out from Paterson, where Hurrican was
accused and tried for murder. My dad actually
covered the Paterson bureau as a reporter during
the entire incident.
  
And let's not forget...
By RachelGoodman Mar 4th 2005 at 10:08 am EST
While we're talking seminal punk: The Clash, with their fabulously British rage, and the Dead Kennedys, who held even California Democratic Governor Jerry Brown to a higher standard when they imagined his inner monologue with delightful angst, "Carter power will soon go away/ I will be Fuhrer someday."

Also, we can't be having this coversation without mentioning queer women's folk-rock. Like so many other women of my generation, listening to Ani DiFranco was a big part of my coming to politics. 1999's "To the Teeth," with Maceo Parker, inspired me with a track on the murder of abortion provider Dr. Barnett Slepian and one on the culture of guns and violence in America. On September 11, 2001, when I voted in New Haven's mayoral primary, Ani's lyrics from the former rattled around in my brain: "I am feeling oh so powerless, in this booth, with this stupid little lever in my hand..."
  
The Lips are Good, but he got the wrong album
By MattSinger Mar 4th 2005 at 1:32 pm EST
Flaming Lips - Transmissions from the Satellite Heart

Soul Coughing - Ruby Vroom

The Mars Volta - De-Loused in the Comatorium

...And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead - Worlds Apart

Deltron - Deltron 3030

The Streets - Original Pirate Material

Tool - Aenima

Fiona Apple - When the Pawn
  
The Ramones?
By CommieInAVolvo Mar 5th 2005 at 10:51 pm EST
So was Johnny Ramone the only Republican?

Anyway, Mos Def's 'Modern Marvel' off of his latest record deserves to be mentioned. The final third of the nine minute song is a passionate call to search justice and a tribute to Marvin Gaye. I also recommend 'What Is Beef?' which featured a collaboration with Talib Kweli on Chappele's Show.
More
By halperindavid Mar 7th 2005 at 2:30 pm EST
Johnny was, I think, the only Republican, at least of the original 4 to 5 Ramones. Joey was definitely liberal, DeeDee marched to his own drummer, and, as for the actual drummers, they mostly drummed. Regarding Mos Def, by the way, we're hoping to feature him on this site soon.
  
Campus Progress

Please remember that Campus Progress' terms of use do not allow promoting or endorsing any particular political party or candidate for office. Posts or comments that do this will be deleted.

Campus Progress